Side-by-Side · 2026
1st Optimal vs Alloy Women's Health: Prices, Programs & Reviews
Quick Verdict
Alloy Women's Health wins on 2 of 8 measurable dimensions, including stronger editorial score (83/100), lower starting price ($49/mo). 1st Optimal stays competitive on visit model and formulation breadth.
1st Optimal
Editorial score 71/100
1st Optimal vs Alloy Women's Health: Full Comparison(8)
Criteria sorted editorial-curated. Winner of each dimension highlighted.
| Criterion | 1st Optimal | Alloy Women's Health |
|---|---|---|
| Editorial score | 71/100 | 83/100 |
| Starting price | $89/mo | $49/mo |
| Insurance accepted | No | No |
| States available | 30 states | 28 states |
| Visit model | sync-video | async |
| Time to first consult | — | — |
| Published outcomes | None | None |
| External rating | — | — |
Editorial score
1st Optimal
71/100Alloy Women's Health
83/100Starting price
1st Optimal
$89/moAlloy Women's Health
$49/moInsurance accepted
1st Optimal
NoAlloy Women's Health
NoStates available
1st Optimal
30 statesAlloy Women's Health
28 statesVisit model
1st Optimal
sync-videoAlloy Women's Health
asyncTime to first consult
1st Optimal
—Alloy Women's Health
—Published outcomes
1st Optimal
NoneAlloy Women's Health
NoneExternal rating
1st Optimal
—Alloy Women's Health
—= wins this dimension. Comparison data refreshed quarterly from editorial review + provider data.
The Bottom Line
Alloy Women's Health edges out 1st Optimal on 2 of 8 dimensions. Alloy Women's Health is the stronger pick if you weight editorial scoring, pricing transparency, and state coverage equally. 1st Optimal may still be right if you prefer its specific medication formulation or visit cadence.
Decision shortcut: take the matcher quiz to factor in your symptoms, insurance, and location.